I used to think that cleansing oils were ideal for oily skin. Many others with oily skin believed the same. Because these oils were praised everywhere, from skincare blogs to YouTube tutorials.

So when I started building a routine for my oily skin, I naturally reached for one. Everyone seemed to love them. At first, I thought it was working. But after a few weeks, I stopped getting random bumps and redness. That’s when I began to question whether oil cleansing had been too harsh for me.

What I Expected from Cleansing Oils for Oily Skin — and What Really Happened

They looked luxurious, felt smooth, and promised deep cleansing without drying out the skin. I had read so many positive reviews about cleansing oils for oily skin. I really thought they would suit my needs.

The idea of melting away makeup, sunscreen, and impurities with a smooth oil sounded both effective and luxurious. Many skincare enthusiasts praised oil cleansers for their gentle approach, especially for removing stubborn products without stripping the skin.

My skin tends to feel tight after washing. I thought an oil cleanser would provide the perfect balance between deep cleaning and hydration. I chose one that looked well-reviewed and suited for all skin types.

The first time I used it, I was impressed. The texture was silky and glided effortlessly, and left no dry patches after rinsing. My face felt clean but not squeaky — which I assumed was a good sign. For a few days, everything seemed fine. I enjoyed the routine, and honestly, I looked forward to that smooth, spa-like texture every evening.

But after about a week, I started to notice something subtle. My T-zone seemed noticeably greasier the next morning. I began to see small bumps around my nose and chin — nothing major, but enough to make me pause. I thought maybe it was just a temporary adjustment, so I kept going. A few more days passed, and the feeling of clogged pores didn’t improve. I noticed that my pores looked more visible than usual in certain areas.

It wasn’t a dramatic breakout or irritation, but my skin wasn’t as balanced or comfortable as it used to be. It was as if something wasn’t sitting quite right. That’s when I started to reconsider whether oil cleansing was a good fit for me.

I Tried Different Types of Cleansing Oils

Once I noticed my skin wasn’t responding well to the first oil cleanser I tried, I didn’t give up immediately. I assumed the problem might be the formula, not the method itself. So I began testing different types of cleansing oils — hoping to find one that worked better with my skin.

First, I looked for options labeled “for oily or combination skin.” Some of them were marketed as lightweight or non-comedogenic. I tried a product that claimed to be mineral oil-free, thinking it might feel less heavy. It did feel a bit lighter in texture, but unfortunately, the results weren’t very different. I explored several cleansing oils formulated for oily skin, including fragrance-free and non-comedogenic versions. My skin still felt like it had a residue afterward and noticed more shine than usual by the next morning.

I moved on to a fragrance-free version next, just in case my skin was reacting to added scent. The formula was simple, and I appreciated that it didn’t have any strong smells. It glided on nicely and rinsed off without much trouble. But again, within a few days, the same things happened. My skin lost clarity. I noticed a few small bumps and an oilier appearance in the center of my face.

Thinking it might be an emulsification issue, I changed the way I applied the product. I followed the instructions carefully: dry hands, dry face, then massage the oil in for about a minute. After that, I added a bit of water to emulsify and rinsed thoroughly. I even followed up with a second cleanser — a gentle foam — just to make sure everything was removed. But even with the double cleansing method, my skin still didn’t feel quite right.

Then I experimented with cleansing balms, which are similar to oils but come in a solid form. I thought the balm texture might give me more control. However, they still left my skin feeling less refreshed after a few days of use. It wasn’t irritation or redness — more like a lingering film.

In total, I tested about five different cleansing oils and two balms over a few months. I spaced them out. I kept the rest of my routine the same. This way, I could really tell how each product worked. Regardless of the brand, texture, or technique, my skin consistently didn’t feel as balanced. It also didn’t feel as fresh as I expected.

To be fair, I know cleansing oils work wonderfully for a lot of people. Some of my friends swear by them, and I’ve seen glowing reviews from people with dry or normal skin. For me, it was different. I have oily areas and skin that tends to clog easily. The more I tried to make oil cleansing work, the more my skin resisted it.

I also started to feel like I was forcing something that didn’t feel natural for me. Each time I washed my face, I hoped it would feel lighter or cleaner. When it didn’t, I felt disappointed. That’s when it occurred to me: maybe the issue wasn’t the product itself. But the fact that it simply didn’t match my skin’s needs.

How My Oily Skin Reacted to Cleansing Oils Over Time

I tried different cleansing oils. I paid close attention to how my skin responded. This included not just immediately after washing but also throughout the day. One of the first things I noticed was that my skin felt weighed down, especially in the T-zone. After cleansing, there was a brief moment of softness, but that feeling didn’t last long. By midday, my forehead and nose looked shinier than usual. I felt like my skin was producing more oil than before.

It wasn’t that the oil cleanser made my skin visibly worse overnight, but I could sense that something was off. In the mornings, there was a slight stickiness around my cheeks. And I noticed a kind of surface dullness. It felt like my skin wasn’t able to breathe properly. It was like a texture was sitting on top that didn’t belong there.

I also began to notice that certain areas, like around my nose and chin, felt more clogged. I didn’t see major breakouts or red spots, but I felt small bumps under the surface of my skin. My pores appeared more prominent than usual, almost like they weren’t being fully cleared. I kept thinking, “Is this just an adjustment phase?” but after several weeks, the pattern was too consistent to ignore.

What frustrated me the most was how inconsistent my skin became. Some mornings felt okay, but on others, my face felt much oilier than usual — despite having the same routine. It made me question if I was pushing my skin in the wrong direction.

I’ve seen people with dry or sensitive skin rave about cleansing oils. They help restore moisture and remove makeup without causing irritation. Some of my friends say their skin became softer and more balanced after switching to oil-based cleansers. I’m genuinely happy that it works for them. It reminded me how skincare results can vary from person to person.

Over time, I also noticed how I felt emotionally about my routine. Instead of enjoying my cleansing time like before, I started to feel uncertain. Each night, I’d wonder whether my skin would feel better or worse the next day. That kind of doubt made me question whether this method was worth continuing. It became clear to me that skincare should feel intuitive — not a guessing game.

It was becoming obvious — no matter how many versions I tested, my oily skin didn’t enjoy oil cleansing. No matter how carefully I applied it or how many versions I tested. It wasn’t a dramatic failure — no redness, no stinging, no major breakouts. But it didn’t feel like the right fit for my skin. And sometimes, knowing what doesn’t work is just as valuable as finding something that does.

Why I Replaced Cleansing Oils with Gel Cleansers for My Oily Skin

I tried different cleansing oils for several months. I didn’t get the results I hoped for. So, I decided to go back to basics. I stopped focusing on what was trending and instead asked myself what actually made my skin feel clean and balanced. That’s when I shifted to using a water-based gel cleanser as my main cleansing step.

The first thing I noticed was how much lighter my skin felt after washing. Unlike oil cleansers, gel cleansers rinsed off completely. Oil cleansers left a soft film, which some people love, but gel cleansers left no residue. My skin didn’t feel tight or dry, but it also didn’t feel coated. It was a comfortable in-between — clean, but not stripped.

I started using a low-foaming gel cleanser formulated for combination or oily skin. The formula I picked had a short ingredient list and no strong fragrance. At night, I used it once—sometimes twice, if I had worn sunscreen or light makeup during the day.

There were no dramatic overnight changes, but after the first week, I realized that my skin felt more predictable. I didn’t wake up with extra shine on my forehead. My nose also didn’t feel sticky in the mornings like it had before.

Over time, I also felt like the texture of my skin improved. There was less of that congested feeling in my T-zone, and my cheeks felt more balanced. I could still get the occasional blemish, especially around my cycle. However, the overall sense of heaviness and oil buildup had reduced. More importantly, I didn’t feel unsure about my cleansing step anymore — it became something I could rely on.

On days when I wore sunscreen or sheer foundation, I used micellar water on a cotton pad. I did this occasionally as a first step. Also used a mild cleansing water. But honestly, most days, the gel cleanser alone was enough. I simplified my routine because it worked better for my skin. Trying to “double-cleanse” with unsuitable products was not effective.

My current evening routine is simple:

1. Gentle gel cleanser (no strong actives or scents)
2. Hydrating toner or essence (lightweight, no alcohol)
3. Light serum when needed
4. Moisturizer

In the morning, I usually just rinse with water or use a splash of toner before applying moisturizer and sunscreen. That’s it.

Going back to a lighter cleansing method didn’t just help my skin. It also made my routine feel easier to stick to. I wasn’t chasing a perfect trend or expecting instant results. I was just trying to support my skin without overwhelming it.

Everyone’s skin is different. For some people, cleansing oils might feel perfect and do exactly what they need. But for me, especially with my oily-prone skin, a gentle gel cleanser has been a better match. It keeps things simple and gives me the clean feeling I was looking for all along — without the weight.

I don’t think oil cleansing is bad or wrong. It just didn’t fit my skin’s needs. Sometimes, the best skincare decision is to step back. Listen to your skin and go with what feels truly comfortable.

Reflection – Why It Didn’t Work for Me

Looking back on my experience, I don’t believe that cleansing oils are bad. In fact, I can completely understand why so many people enjoy using them. They can feel luxurious, offer a smooth texture, and remove makeup efficiently. Some people even describe them as the most gentle way to cleanse the skin — and I don’t disagree. It’s just that, for me, the experience didn’t turn out the way I expected.

I have naturally oily skin, especially in the T-zone. My forehead, nose, and chin tend to get shiny quickly. The rest of my face stays relatively balanced. When I started using oil cleansers, I believed I was adding a helpful step. I thought it would support my skin instead of challenging it. But over time, my skin didn’t seem to agree with that kind of texture. The texture seemed thick and occasionally sticky, and not as fresh as I wanted.

I also noticed that using oils made it harder for me to feel in tune with my skin. With gel cleansers or water-based routines, I could tell right away if my skin was feeling calm, dry, or sensitive. But with oil cleansing, everything felt blurred. It was like there was a thin layer between me and understanding what my skin truly needed.

For people with dry or sensitive skin, cleansing oils can be a comforting part of their routine. They offer a cushion that helps avoid the tightness or discomfort that sometimes comes with foaming cleansers. I’ve heard great stories from friends who say their skin became softer and less reactive after switching to oils. I’m genuinely glad it works for them — and I wouldn’t tell anyone to avoid trying it.

But for those with oily or congestion-prone skin, I would suggest starting slowly. Try it on days when you’re not wearing a lot of products. Pay close attention to how your skin feels a few hours later — not just right after cleansing. Also, don’t be afraid to stop if something doesn’t feel right. Just because a product is popular or praised doesn’t mean it’s the right fit for everyone.

I’ve learned that “gentle” doesn’t always mean “suitable.” Some products are soft in feel but still create issues depending on skin type and environment. Cleansing oils are too rich for my skin. They don’t work well with how my skin behaves, especially in humid weather. They also cause issues after long days outdoors.

Another thing I realized is that skincare should feel intuitive. If I’m constantly questioning whether a product is working, it might not be the best match for me. I also wonder whether I’m using it the “right way.” When I switched back to a basic gel cleanser, everything became simpler. This change affected not just my routine, but also how I understood my skin. I don’t regret trying oil cleansers. They taught me a lot about how my skin reacts to different textures and ingredients. They also helped me understand that chasing trends isn’t always the answer. Sometimes, less really is more — especially when it comes to skincare.

I’m not saying cleansing oils are bad. I’m saying they weren’t for me. And that’s okay. Skincare is personal, and what works beautifully for one person might not work the same for another.

Final Thoughts on Why Cleansing Oils Didn’t Work for My Oily Skin

If you’re considering cleansing oils for oily skin, just know that results may vary — and that’s okay. Skincare is a personal journey, and what works for one person may not work for another. I learned this the hard way. I was trying to make cleansing oils fit into my routine. But my skin was clearly telling me otherwise.

For me, stepping away from oil cleansers was a turning point. I came to understand that my skin prefers lighter textures and simpler routines. More importantly, it reminded me that it’s okay to change direction — especially when something doesn’t feel right. There’s no shame in saying, “This isn’t for me.”

You don’t need to stick with something just because it seems like the “right” thing. What matters most is how your skin feels and responds — not the label on the bottle.

Don’t be afraid to change what doesn’t work.

Your skin, your rules.

Wondering what I use now? I’ve shared a simple, lightweight list of the toners I trusted during my one-month experiment.

If you’re also exploring your skincare routine, you might find my post helpful. It discusses building a Korean-style routine for oily or combination skin.

Thanks for reading, and I hope you find what truly works for you — without pressure or hype.

Disclaimer: This post reflects personal experience only and is not intended as medical advice. 

Looking for more personal skincare reflections like this?

I occasionally share simple tips. I also share honest routines and product stories. These have worked for my real skin — no trends, no noise.

No spam. No promotions. Just real-life insights.

👉 Join my email list and be the first to read my next story.